Outhouses on the First Floor

old-age-home-in-bangaloreThe very few who responded to my  yesterday’s post, ‘Coming of (Old)Age in India‘ could be divided into two groups with opposing views.

One is shocked with children neglecting or even abusing the parents who nursed them from infancy. They are sad about                                                  the elders being kept in old-age homes, abandoned or put to sleep.

The other group feels that it is nothing unusual and that the modern youth, with both spouses employed, cannot be expected to take care of the parents. “They don’t have the time” even if they have the resources.

Row houses, pent-houses and villas are a part of the deliberate, conscious, effort of affluent modern  young men and women to keep the parents out of their lives. Privacy is the name of the game. They can escape seeing the ‘oldies’ for days together. The few times they cross each other, the conversation is limited to monosyllables. Most often ‘golden silence’ prevails.

The grandson is instructed by his mother not to speak to the grandparents and to ignore them even when they call him. The servants are told not to do what the ‘oldies’ ask them to. If they still serve the old people it is only because their poverty has kept alive their culture of respecting the aged. It has not killed in them that useless appendage to the mind, called conscience. Affluence has not wiped it out as yet.

No one pities or sympathizes with these aged. All would think they are living happily with their children and grandchildren in luxury homes. Not all old people are that ‘fortunate’. There also are many who do live literally in outhouses of their sons’ grand houses, in old-age homes, in ancestral village homes while their progeny enjoy life of urban luxury.

Some, live  alone in city apartments while  sons or daughters working abroad.  Some  live on footpaths, abandoned by the children they brought up at great sacrifice.  A story that did rounds for months on WhatsApp tells of a mother on her death-bed in an old-age home making a last wish — donate some cooling fans  to the home. Why this wish when she lived there for years without AC or fans? “I am on way out and do not need them, but used to air-conditioners, you will suffer when your children send you here,” she says.

The country was shocked and stunned when Aamir Khan, in his thought-provoking talk show ‘Satyameva Jayate’,  devoted one episode to the plight of the aged . He brought to light an  investigative report by a woman journalist  on how in south Tamil Nadu there was a ritualistic ending of the lives of old parents after a ceremonial ‘head bath’.

The  exposure may have reduced this ‘abominable practice’ to the same extent as the socially accepted custom of child marriage in Rajasthan and Bihar was reduced by enacting a law against it. Both practices continue as we, a ‘civilized modern society’, sweep them under the carpet to pretend that they do not exist.

The Tamil Nadu practice, perhaps, was what the aged parents  wanted – at least a substantial number of them. It could be that many of them themselves chose  it. Ritualizing it by giving it a religious colour or making it a tradition cleared the conscience of the sons (daughters have no say in such matters) who practiced it and those  who participated  in it.

For the willing aged it may be a welcome escape from the harsh reality of existing in a country which is no haven for senior citizens. Indian health-care system provides for hospitals but not hospices. Geriatrics as a medical specialization is unheard of.

Doctors prescribe surgeries like by-pass or dialysis for 80-year-olds, with an eye on the money they can make from such procedures, rather than the patients’ well-being. The rule that a doctor’s prime duty is to save lives is adhered to in its (more profitable) letter rather than its spirit. They are unconcerned about the physically and mentally painful quality of the lives so ‘saved’.

The number of the aged people who pray for death, who see it as a deliverance from a life of pain, worthlessness and a burden on those they love, may be much higher than what is believed.

Thousands of bed-ridden people leading a vegetative existence may prefer to end the ordeal. But very few try as they do not know how to do it painlessly. Or they have the fatalistic belief that it was their Karma – that they were destined to live on.  Most of those who do not try to end it may perhaps be deterred only by the fear that pain and suffering may precede death, as it does most of the time.

The destination is desirable and reaching it is inevitable, but the road is a difficult one. They lack the courage to step on to it. A sudden, painless, death is what most people want and hope for, rather than a long life. Very few may want to be blessed to “live a hundred years” (Sau saal Jiyo).  Longevity is no more a blessing. Many may consider it a curse.

I do.

These are the issues I wanted to deal with in the book that may never come out: THE OUTHOUSE ON THE FIRST FLOOR -Coming of (Old)Age In India.




  1. I wish someone would take up writing the book on coming of old-age in India which I started and dropped. I will provide a lot of background notes I collected. Hundreds of very old people are abandoned in hopsitlas and at bus stops of other places and sometimes their poverty and helplessness makes their children do it. The law on demanding maintenance (I have the full text) is thee, but how many parents would use it? They would rather suffer than harm “family prestige”. If someone can contact publishers and get acceptance, I canfinishthe book provided I life long enough to complete it.


    1. You clicked on ‘like’ first and then disliked what was written. I was twice in the US and did not find any doormat/toilet seat/underwear with Lincoln, US flag, Jesus or Pope n on them. Why only Indian gods and goddesses? I never quoted any Muslim writer. ‘Bose’, if I am not wrong can only be a Bengali Hindu (or a Keralite) It was a Pakistani website that expressed glee at the doormats and found fault with Indians for protesting. If you are such a great advocate for their cause please ask why there was violence all over the world for cartoons or pictures of the Prophet and why blasphemy laws in Pakistan and other Islamic countries are so strict. In India we make fun of gods and do not protest. In Vidarbha region every year after the Ganesh festival with huge idols some ‘Maskaria Ganapati’ idols, with Ganesh dressed as a film star or doing funny things, also come up. A Telugu writer wrote Muppala Ranganayakamma, ‘Ramayana Vishavruksham’ depicting Rama as villain and in Kerala a film was made giving a casteist interpretation to Ramayan showing Rama as an oppressor.
      I would like to see your blog praising these and the doormats with Indian flags, made obviously to attract some anti-Indian groups and gain worldwide publicity. No commercial company would manufacture anything unless there is a market for it. Did you go to Calgary or Toronto and any other city in Canada and not find thousands of Punjabis there? Do you deny that the anti-Indian Khalistan movement was directed from Canada?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s